It was supposed to be a simple promo stunt: A FESTIVAL is looking for a newcomer for the last remaining DJ slot on the mainstage via Instagram. The assignment for the community: „Drop a comment telling us what sound you’d bring.“

What unfolded in the comment section, however, wasn’t exactly a showcase of creative musical visions. It was more a testament to absolute uniformity and the terminal stage of musical identity loss. This whole mess started a while ago when Eurodance was suddenly sold as Trance, right alongside Beatport’s hardcore shitty genre definitions.

Time for some much-needed clarification. What the DJs write vs. what it actually means in reality:

The „Indie Dance“ Illusion and the Beatport Shopping Cart Syndrome

  • The Comment Section Madness: DJs apply with a „symbiosis of Indie Dance and Tech House“ and serve up references like DON’T BLINK, Stil vor Talent, or Temple Tears.
  • The Reality: The aforementioned Beatport Shopping Cart Syndrome hitting with full force.
  • What it’s NOT: DON’T BLINK is pure, functional, mass-produced Tech House. For years, Stil vor Talent has stood for that pleasing, easy-listening melodic sound meant for a lazy Sunday afternoon. Absolutely zero of this has anything to do with Indie Dance.
  • What it REALLY is: Genuine Indie Dance is a filthy head-on collision between guitar music and club culture. It’s raw post-punk attitude, dirty 80s synths, and analog machines. If you say Indie Dance, you better mean label classics like DFA Records (LCD Soundsystem) or Ed Banger. Today, the genre lives on in Dark Disco, heavily borrowing from EBM through acts like Damon Jee, Curses, or Italodisco à la Dina Summer.

The „Bounce“ Pandemic

  • The Comment Section Madness: From „Bouncy Psy-Tech“ and „HardTechno Bounce“ to the physically impossible „Melodic bounce down tempo.“ And the absolute rhetorical total write-off: „Sound for hot waffles with the necessary drip drop bounce.“
  • The Reality: „Bounce“ is the current non-word of the electronic scene and a dumping ground for musical irrelevance.
  • What it’s NOT: It is not a real, organically grown subgenre. Classic Chicago House and Jackin‘ House (think Cajual Records, Derrick Carter, or DJ Sneak) bounce like hell. But that bounce comes from swing.
  • What it REALLY is: It’s a nebulous buzzword for hyperactive, TikTok-optimized hard dance tracks. It boils down to an obnoxious offbeat bass designed not to make the crowd groove, but to make them hop up and down like they’re on a fucking trampoline. Anyone demanding or offering „bounce“ isn’t looking for depth; they’re looking for clumsy sensory overload tailored to a three-second attention span.

„Peaktime“ Is Not a Genre (And Acid Doesn’t Need Incense Sticks)

  • The Comment Section Madness: „Melodic Peaktime Techno,“ garnished with „spherical acid tracks“ and „beautiful trance elements.“
  • The Reality: This is just blindly grabbing from the festival Lego set without having the faintest clue what the words actually mean.
  • Peaktime: Describes exactly one thing: the energy level and the tension arc on the floor. It is NOT a genre.
  • Acid: „Spherical acid tracks“ is an acoustic oxymoron. The Roland TB-303 scratches, corrodes, and drills straight into your brain. That is uncompromising energy and most definitely not watered-down, incense-stick ambient.
  • Trance: What gets labeled as „Trance“ today is structurally just reheated, glorified Eurodance from ’94. Unbelievably shitty music.

Minimal House and the Over-50s Beer Tent Party

  • The Comment Section Madness: „Bouncy Minimal House“ combined with „cheeky rap elements“ that immediately make your „dancing leg“ twitch.
  • The Reality: A total failure on every conceivable level.
  • What it’s NOT: Minimal and „bouncy“ are mutually exclusive. You either strip things down to the hypnotic essentials, or you build a bouncy castle. Pick one.
  • What it REALLY is: Genuine minimalism looks to the blueprint of Robert Hood’s Minimal Nation. „Cheeky“ is an adjective reserved for unfunny morning radio hosts. In a club context, „cheeky rap elements“ usually just means some hack carelessly slapped an exhausted 90s hip-hop a cappella over a loop. And anyone who uses phrases like „dancing leg“ has rhetorically disqualified themselves from anything other than the over-50s beer tent party on the village square.

The Final Bosses of Cluelessness

When musical arguments are completely absent, things just get Dadaist. The absolute capitulation to having any kind of coherent thread shows up in comments like:

„Nudisco/downmid Tempo Deep organic melodic house Fasttempo!“

How someone plans to play „downmid“ and „Fasttempo“ simultaneously in the exact same vibe remains the exclusive secret of this particular genius.

„PeakTime Reggaeton“

For the mainstage. Nothing more needs to be said.

A DJ booth is not a safe space for people who haven’t done their musical homework. And you can’t expect a general amnesty for playing musical buzzword bingo. Anyone who thinks they can fast-track their way onto a stage using trendy keywords and emojis instead of actually developing their own musical identity has fundamentally failed to understand club culture.

Verwandte ArtikelMehr vom Autor